The 7 best document management software tools to optimise HR processes

Managing HR documents can be chaotic and frustrating, and it can feel nearly impossible to keep employee files and data organised. But it doesn’t have to be that way.

With document management software, you can effortlessly and securely manage files, streamline workflows and access important documents in just a few clicks. 

By saving you the time usually spent chasing down and updating paperwork, document management frees you up to focus on more impactful tasks, like refining your HR strategy and improving employee experience.

In this article, we compare leading document management systems. Each solution was chosen for its range of features, with careful consideration paid to user reviews and ease of use.

Our pick of the best document management software for 2024

  1. Personio: Best for robust and integrated document management

  2. Breathe: Best for cost-conscious small businesses in the UK

  3. Myhrtoolkit: Best for basic document management needs

  4. Eddy: Best for tracking compliance and employee certifications

  5. Zoho People: Best for customisable document management 

  6. Access People HR: Best for unlimited document storage

  7. MyDocSafe: Best for secure and advanced document management

7 top documentation software options for 2024

1. Personio

Electronic Signature Send Contract

Personio’s comprehensive HR management software is designed to streamline all your HR operations, including document management

The platform provides a secure, centralised repository for storing HR documents, from employee contracts and CVs to performance reviews and company policies. 

Personio’s access controls ensure only authorised users can view or edit specific documents. The software also includes version control that tracks changes over time. 

The platform comes with templates that standardise and speed up document creation and an e-signature tool that ensures documents are signed legally and quickly. 

Personio also automatically reminds you of important dates such as contract expiration, so nothing slips through the cracks. Meanwhile, integrations with other business tools, like email and cloud storage, simplify file sharing and collaboration.

Top features

  • Centralised storage: Securely store and manage every HR and employee document from the same organised place.

  • Digital employee files: Get a comprehensive overview of each employee, including secure access to their employee documents.

  • Automated workflows: Streamline document management by automating key tasks like document requests, approvals and reminders.

  • Access and version controls: Track document changes and manage who can view, edit or delete documents with custom permissions.

  • HR document templates: Use pre-designed templates to easily standardise and streamline your document creation.

  • Extensive integrations: Sync documents with 200+ of your most important email, collaboration, productivity and communication tools.

Collect employee signatures instantly and compliantly

Electronic Signature Browser Offer Signed Confirmation

Personio’s electronic signature software streamlines the employee document management process to save you time, paper and money.

Learn more

Pros

Cons

Secure storage, access controls and GDPR-compliant data protections 

Personio’s solution is built for organisations in Europe and the UK and may be less optimised for regions outside of these.

Embedded within Personio’s comprehensive HR platform

Fantastic customer support, according to G2 users

2. Breathe

Breathe’s HR software comes with built-in document management features. The platform prioritises simplicity and is designed for small businesses with less than 200 employees.  

Breathe provides unlimited online storage for HR documents, enabling organisations to organise all their documents in one location. Its HR dashboard provides at-a-glance insights, such as tracking which employees have read a company policy. 

Like Personio, Breathe is fully GDPR-compliant, encrypts HR data and offers access control to protect sensitive documents.

However, Breathe’s simplified features may not be enough for larger organisations requiring more powerful document control software.

Top features 

  • Unlimited storage: Store and organise all HR documents without reaching capacity.

  • Document tracking and reminders: Track who has read documents and easily send reminders.

  • GDPR compliance: Protect documents with encrypted storage and privacy controls.

Pros

Cons

Simple and easy-to-use, according to G2 users

Some G2 users complain that the tool is not easily customisable. 

Helpful customer support team, according to G2 users

GDPR compliance and encryption that provide data protection

3. Myhrtoolkit

Designed for small- to medium-sized businesses, Myhrtoolkit offers document management software as part of its broader HR systems offering. One of its key features is the HR digital library, where you can securely store and manage all HR documents. 

The platform ensures documents are easily accessible and includes features like document tracking and automated reminders for expiring documents.

Like Breathe, Myhrtoolkit is best suited for companies that don’t require advanced features. As one GetApp reviewer notes, the platform covers the basics well but lacks the intuitive design of more advanced offerings. 

Top features 

  • HR digital library: Store and manage all HR documents in one secure location.

  • Document access controls: Ensure employees only see the documents that are relevant to them.

  • Automated reminders: Get notified when documents are about to expire.

Pros

Cons

Secure and encrypted storage for HR documents

The tool is designed for small businesses in the UK so may not be as suited for  organisations or teams based elsewhere. 

The ability to organise documents into categories like inductions, handbooks and procedures

Good customer support, as highlighted by Capterra users

4. Eddy

Eddy offers a balanced mix of document management features that make it a good business solution for medium- and even small-sized organisations. 

The platform centralises the handling of essential documents, such as employment contracts and policy acknowledgements.These can be e-signed directly within the platform. 

Eddy also provides automated alerts for expiring certifications and compliance documents. These documents are easily accessible for audits, so Eddy is a good option for industries where strict adherence to regulations is essential.

Top features 

  • E-signature tool: Facilitate legal document signing directly within the platform.

  • Compliance tracking: Receive notifications when compliance documents and employee certifications are expiring.

  • Document management system: Centralise and securely store employee documents.

Pros

Cons

Document management system embedded in an all-in-one HR solution 

Document compliance is targeted towards US organisations, so it may not be suitable for businesses located elsewhere. 

Compliance tracking

Easy to use, according to G2 users

5. Zoho People

Zoho People’s robust HR document management system comes with tools to store employee records, compliance forms and other critical documents. 

The platform enables employees to upload and manage their documents directly, while HR teams can generate documents in bulk using customisable templates. 

Zoho People also features e-signature workflows that automate document delivery, secure signatures and store files automatically.

While these features are powerful, some users note that the platform isn’t always user-friendly, which can impact how much value you’re able to get out of it. 

Top features 

  • Customisable document templates: Create and manage documents in bulk using pre-designed templates.

  • Automated e-signature workflows: Custom workflows deliver documents, secure signatures and store files.

  • Employee self-service: Employees can upload and manage their documents directly through a portal.

Pros

Cons

Customisation options

Some Capterra users complain of issues with customer support. 

Security measures for sensitive HR documents

Multiple pricing tiers aimed at different organisational sizes and needs 

6. Access People HR

Bundled as part of an all-in-one HR offering, Access People HR comes with a document management system and unlimited document storage. 

The platform’s smart search functionality can help you quickly find the documents and role-based access ensures that only the right people can view sensitive information. Automated alerts mean you’ll know when a compliance document is about to expire.

While Access People HR offers solid document management features, some G2 users report that the platform can be difficult to navigate, especially during the initial setup. This can add frustration to the onboarding process. 

Top features 

  • Unlimited document storage: Securely store all your HR documents. 

  • Employee self-service portal: Enable employees to access and manage their own HR documents.

  • Compliance tracking: Receive alerts when compliance documents and employee certifications are expiring.

Pros

Cons

Enhanced security thanks to document access controls

Some G2 users complain of an unintuitive design coupled with a limited mobile app.

Helps ensure accurate and up-to-date employee records

Document management included in an all-in-one HR platform

7. MyDocSafe

MyDocSafe’s secure document management solution is designed for general-purpose use, making it versatile for various industries and organisation sizes. 

The platform has file-sharing tools for sending documents or files bundles to clients or internal teams and tracking features that reveal whether documents are opened and by whom.

Security is a core focus, and the platform offers advanced features like data encryption and two-factor authentication. 

While MyDocSafe comes with advanced document management software, it’s not tailored specifically for HR departments. So if you need to integrate it with your existing HR tech stack, you may be looking at increased complexity and cost. 

Top features 

  • Audit trails: Maintain version control and track document activities while generating full access logs.

  • Document templates: Streamline and standardise document creation across your organisation. 

  • E-signature tools: Secure legally binding electronic signatures for key documents.

Pros

Cons

Electronic signatures features for streamlined onboarding

MyDocSafe isn’t an HR-specific tool, which may complicate the process of connecting it to your existing HR tech stack.

Security tools, like audit trails and encryption keys

Secure cloud sharing capabilities 

What to look for in a document management system

To ensure your whole team embraces and makes the most of new document management, it needs to be easy to use and provide clear value. 

The right HR system should also make managing documents easier, faster and more accurate, freeing up your time to focus on other important tasks. 

With this in mind, here are some additional features to look out for when choosing a tool: 

  • Centralised storage: Your platform should provide a centralised location to store all HR documents, including employee contracts, performance reviews and policies. It should also aid HR teams in quickly retrieving and updating documents as needed.

  • Document workflow automation: Automation eliminates tedious and time-consuming manual processes, freeing up your schedule to focus on tasks that are more impactful than chasing signatures and approvals.

  • Document templates: To save time, your management tool should make standardising and creating documents quick and simple while ensuring the right information is in the right documents.

  • Integration capabilities: The best document management systems connect seamlessly with existing HR and payroll systems. This integration is essential for eliminating information silos and ensuring that all systems are up-to-date with the latest information.

  • Security and compliance tools: You need to have strong security measures in place, in order to keep sensitive employee information safe, like controlling who can access certain documents.  Your document management software should also help you stay compliant with data protection laws like GDPR by making it easy to manage who can access, store and delete data.

Overview of best document management tools

Document management tool

Top features

Best for

Personio

Digital employee files

Document templates

Any business needing robust and integrated HR document management

Breathe

Unlimited storage

Document tracking and reminders

Cost-conscious small and medium-sized businesses in the UK

Myhrtoolkit

HR digital library

Document access controls

Small to medium-sized organisations with basic document management needs

Eddy

Compliance tracking

E-signature tool

Small to medium-sized organisations prioritising compliance and employee certification tracking

Zoho People

Document templates

Automated e-signature workflows

Organisations of any size looking for customisable document management

Access People HR

Unlimited document storage

Compliance tracking

Small to medium-sized organisations looking for unlimited document storage

MyDocSafe

Audit trails

Document templates

Security-conscious organisations looking for advanced document management software

Centralise your HR documentation in one easy-to-use platform

personio digital employee file shrm
With Personio, you can effortlessly store HR data in one place - error-free, complete, and legally compliant.

The best document management software streamlines your HR processes while ensuring sensitive information is securely managed and easily accessible by the right people. 

As you explore your options, consider how each tool aligns with your current needs and whether it can adapt as your organisation grows.

Personio's all-in-one HR solution offers document management software that’s fully integrated with your HR system and workflows. 

Along with centralising your HR documents, Personio equips your teams to perform all your key HR tasks from the same user-friendly platform. Book a demo today to try Personio for yourself.

Keep all your essential employee information at your fingertips

personio business tool digital employee file
You can use Personio to securely store, change and update employee information at the click of a button.

Personio’s digital employee file ensures you always have quick access to important employee data and documents.

Learn more

14 days of Personio. For free.

personio software free trial